"There was an old woman who lived in a shoe.
She had so many children, she didn't know what to do.
She gave them some broth without any bread,
Then whipped them all soundly and put them to bed."
I don't know where to start.
"There was an old woman who lived in a shoe, she had so many children, she didn't know what to do." Move out of the shoe, that's my first piece of advice. Even for a single person the largest shoe will be inadequate accommodation (unless perhaps it's one of those fibreglass ones you sometimes see in children's playgrounds, although they tend to be more of a boot than a shoe), so it simply won't do for a woman with a number of progeny which is indeterminate but definitely high. (The children to whom I was reading this suggested the number could be either 57 or six hundred million billion, either of which is definitely more than a shoeful. Six hundred million billion children is equivalent to one hundred million earth populations, and I'd like to see the shoe big enough to hold one hundred million earths. Then again, it's possible that the author of the rhyme was presciently (and somewhat offhandedly) referring to the recently discovered "cosmic horseshoe", which probably is big enough to contain one hundred million earths. Moreover it is 12 billion years old, definitely marking out its matriarch as an "old woman". But, uncharacteristically, I digress.)
The rhyme doesn't specify about what exactly she didn't know what to do - about living in a shoe, or about having so many children? If it's the shoe then a trip to the Citizen's Advice Bureau is in order, and if it's the children then Social Services should have got involved way before she got anywhere near even 57 (let alone the distant billions). She didn't know what to do about family planning, that's for sure. Although one would imagine that since she's an old woman, many of these children are now fully grown themselves. Why haven't they gone out and made their way in the world, settled down in their own footwear domicile? So many unanswered questions.
However all this is academic when we come to the second couplet. Faced with her inadequacy in housing provision and the positively bacterial quantity of her offspring, what does she do? Unlike most of us when we need a break from our children (we have a bath, we go to the pub, that sort of thing) she reaches for the Campbell's and the cat o'nine tails. I'm sure most parents can relate to that time at the end of the day when everybody is getting tired and tetchy, and the mantra comes out "Right, it's tea, story and bed". I think that's the accepted routine. I've never really gone in for whipping (of any intensity), and I'm not sure she's helping herself with this approach. Quite apart from the welfare issues, whipping that many children - and soundly, mind - must be exhausting. She could be using that energy in so many other, more productive ways. Baking bread, for example, to accompany her boring broth. I think that would make for a much nicer rhyme all round:
"There was an incredibly old woman who lived in a cosmic horseshoe.
She had six hundred million billion children so she clearly didn't know when to say no.
In spite of this she baked a lovely loaf of bread,
Which is why none of her grown-up children had moved out, the wasters."

