by
Captain_Autumn
@ 23/07/2008 - 11:34:09
I was watching an interview with Chris Difford and Glenn Tilbrook last night, an hour long programme called Songbook: Squeeze where they sat and talked about the songwriting process. I was quite surprised to see how current it looked, because they reached a point a decade or so ago when they couldn't work together any more. I knew they were getting back to tour as Squeeze for a few dates last year to promote the re-releases, but that was supposed to be it. It turns out they got on well and it appears they may work together again. Which would be lovely if it happens.
They did a version of Tempted with Glenn Tilbrook at the piano, and much as I was enjoying it there was something I couldn't place which wasn't quite right. It was only when it got to the second verse, where on the record Tilbrook takes the lead vocal for the first time, that I realised - it's one of only two songs of theirs which have the lead taken by Paul Carrack, and as much as I adore Tilbrook's voice it was Carrack that was missing. And it served to remind me that the version of Tempted on East Side Story is about as perfect a pop song as has ever been recorded.
Out of curiosity I had a browse through iTunes to see if there were many cover versions, and of course there are loads - bland versions which remove all the soul, country versions which are an abomination, jazz versions which overcook it, a folk version by Richard Thompson, a bizarre ska version by Regatta 69, even an a cappella version by a sub-Take 6 act called Rockapella... it's like a Noah's Ark of musical styles all trying to put a new slant on this peerless song. Weirdest of all there's a moribund version by Chris Difford, who I suppose at least has the right to murder his own song. And I didn't know whether to laugh or cry at a Jools Holland version - you'd think he'd have realised that the reason East Side Story is Squeeze's best album is because he's not on it.
Anyway, they all highlight the reality that once in a while a combination of music, lyric, personnel, performance and production come together and create something upon which it is simply impossible to improve.
At this point I would embed the YouTube video if I knew how, but I don't. So it's here.