I may be alone in this, but I don't want Michael Phelps to win his eight gold medals. And here's why.
I've got issues with swimming. I've always had issues with swimming, ever since I had to be dragged screaming into primary school on Fridays knowing that it was swimming lesson day. For many a year people tried to teach me to swim, and for many a year they more or less failed. They were still trying when I was 12 or 13 and getting openly derided for it. These days I have to take my kids swimming, and I just sit in the shallow end trying not to panic as they show me how long they can stay underwater. I hate going under the water. Water is dangerous. People drown in it.
So anyway, for me swimming has always been something that you can either do or you can't. Like holding a tune, or mental arithmetic. Such activities can be honed and advanced, but if an individual doesn't have it in them in the first place they'll never get the hang of it. Phelps is clearly someone who can do swimming, and he's obviously worked incredibly hard to get to a position of such dominance and I applaud him for that. Here's my problem with the eight gold medals though. It will be eight gold medals for doing more or less the same thing. Freestyle, butterfly, breaststroke, it's all just swimming. To win a decathlon gold, you've got to be pretty decent in ten different disciplines, and even if you put them into broadly similar categories you still have skills as diverse as running, throwing and jumping. Phelps just has to keep on swimming, swimming, swimming, and people start calling him the greatest ever Olympian. I hope Steve Redgrave gets to award him one of his medals, preferably with a little smirk.
Swimmers out there will, I don't doubt, disagree with me, telling me that swimming butterfly is as different from swimming freestyle as pole vault is from dressage. And speaking from a position of profound ignorance I am happy to be corrected. But I'll still hate swimming.












